So, where does all that leave Keepsake? Well, it has a fantastic story with an ending that is somewhat surprising. It has good controls (really hard to mess that up though). The graphics are beautiful and I generally liked the sounds. Some of the puzzles are really fun. That all sounds so good, it should be a superior product as such. However, that isn't the case at all. If they ended the game at the lower levels, it would have gotten a much better review. The second half of the game really drags it down. The puzzles in the upper levels are more often than not just frustrating or make absolutely no sense. The portal travel gets ridiculous at points. If it weren't for those two (pretty major) points, the game would be a must buy. I want to say buy it because the first half is a sheer joy to play, but it is hard to recommend something when I know you'll want to find out how it ends and getting to the end point might just be more than you can bear. Of course, you can use the hint system to fast forward through it.