Forever Knights members focus on the art of roleplaying—not just within the world of Guild Wars itself, but also by bringing their own stories into the game. They adhere to a code of honor that governs how they act and interact with other players in the game. Upon reaching the rank of Knight, members must swear to uphold these values, which center prominently on respecting fellow gamers.

Forever Knights also makes use of an active awards system. Awards are given out for various accomplishments, which include recruiting new members, being an active long-time member, doing a good deed for the guild, giving the guild a good reputation, participating in outstanding roleplaying, engaging in acts of bravery, or winning one of the guild’s PvP tournaments. These awards are shown as graphics (rings) added next to the names of the members on the guild’s forums and website.