On the down side, there’s everything else. It’s the rare game that manages to disappoint as decisively as Pirates of the Caribbean. The real potential of this title is so readily apparent beneath the surface, it’s easy to forgive anyone who overlooks the flaws and argues that PotC is a good game. In the end, however, the pirate-game-turned-micro-economic-sim Port Royale makes a convincing argument to relegate Pirates of the Caribbean to a bargain bin.