RPGDot Network    
   

 
 
Etherlords
Display full image
Pic of the moment
More
pics from the gallery
 
 

Site Navigation

Main
   News
   Forums

Games
   Games Database
   Top 100
   Release List
   Support Files

Features
   Reviews
   Previews
   Interviews
   Editorials
   Diaries
   Misc

Download
   Gallery
   Music
   Screenshots
   Videos

Miscellaneous
   Staff Members
   Privacy Statement


 

City of Heroes Review
Enich, 2004-06-28

Hear that fanfare? That's the sound of the MMORPG genre leveling up. Cryptic Studios has nailed solutions to some of the gameplay problems that MMORPGs have suffered from, and in an appropriately super-heroic way, making City of Heroes a refreshing change of pace and a joy to play.

Let's go over the basics, shall we, sidekick?

Character Creation

It's true: you can spend hours on end experimenting with costuming options. There are options for everything from hats and masks down to boots, from tights to suits (armored or Armani), and countless modifications available on most pieces to get your look just right. I won't bother listing the different types of costume pieces; there's enough there to do a review just on the costuming system. Each piece of your costume can be individually coloured, with some pieces having the option to place a pattern on top of it. Once you've created your costume, you can only change it through tailoring in game. But, if you join a supergroup, you can reconfigure your costume to use the supergroup's colors. You can't have a cape, at least not yet, but with all the other options it is an easy omission to overlook. Before choosing your costume, you choose a body type: Male, Female, or Huge, and adjust the height and build. You get a good height range to pick from, anywhere from a leprechaunish 4' up to super-NBA levels, and a range of builds to match. You might not be able to get precisely the look you're going for, but with this many options you're certain to get close.

Display full image Display full image Display full image

Before you even get that far, you must pick your hero's origin, archetype, and starting powers. The origins, which are Natural, Science, Magical, Technology, or Mutation, describe how your character acquired their powers, but the in-game effect is rather slight aside from roleplaying potential. Origin determines which power enhancements your hero can use; everyone can use any given type of enhancement, like damage or accuracy, but you're essentially confined to your origin's "brand" of enhancement. In other words, it's like class-only equipment.

Next up is your archetype, which determines what kind of powers you get access to and the roles and strategies you'll have to use in combat. You get your pick of Tank, Scrapper, Blaster, Defender, and Controller, and for the most part their roles are self-explanatory. I say "mostly" because, much like with costuming, you have a lot of options here. All characters get a primary and secondary set of powers, chosen from their archetype's separate primary and secondary set lists, and while the sets for an archetype tend to have some similar function, each has its own quirks and specialties. For instance, one set may concentrate on doing fire damage, while another concentrates on doing knockback, and another specializes in accuracy debuffs; there's a power set for just about everything. You start with one of the first two powers in your primary and secondary sets, and are offered a third power almost immediately after entering the game. The rest of the powers unlock as you gain levels, the primary set opening up faster than the secondary.

Your powers are your equipment. Under the current level cap of 40, you'll only be able to get 20 powers. Since your power sets only have 9 each, at first glance this doesn't appear to be a problem. However, there are also "pool sets", which are small, 4-power sets that concentrate on one kind of power, from which you can pick and choose powers to round out your list and tweak your abilities to fit your style of play. You're a tank, but you want to be able to heal? Try taking Medicine. Want to sneak around, but your power sets don't provide for it? Take Stealth. Got a hankerin' to deal out a heaping helping of ham-sized fists? Take Fighting. Power pools are also the place to go for movement powers. Flight, super running speed, super jumping, and teleportation are all available in their respective pools. Of course, most movement powers are third in the pool list, meaning you'll have to wait til level 14 and have one other power in the pool before you can take it, and the last in the list requires level 20 and any two other powers in the pool, so don't go thinking you'll be able to do group teleports at level 2. Oh, and you can only choose up to four pools to have access to, but unless you practically ignore your main powers this shouldn't be a problem.

Your inventory is simple: one part holds up to ten enhancements, the other holds inspirations. Enhancements are yet another way to specialize your character; you add them to powers to improve their abilities. When you get a new power, it has one enhancement slot available; you can add more slots as you level. New powers are offered up at even security levels, and at odd levels you receive two new enhancement slots to add to your existing powers. There are three grades of enhancements: Training, Double Origin (usable by two different Origin types), and Single Origin (usable by only one Origin type). Training gives the worst percentage bonus to a power's stat, and Single Origin the best. If your enhancement's level is equal to your character level, you get the base bonus. Higher or lower than your level, the enhancement will work slightly better or slightly worse than the base, and too far from your level and it will not work at all.

Your inspirations inventory's capacity increases at certain levels; you start with room for four. Inspirations are short-term stat and resistance boosts, very handy when you just can't seem to hit the boss that's chewing through your team, or to make sure he can't hit you. There are also health and stamina recovery inspirations, great for any occasion. Oh, but the best part about inspirations is...

Dying

Display full image
Well, technically you don't die. Technically, you're teleported to the hospital for treatment just short of death, which beats a swift kick in the pants I suppose, though that may be what got you admitted to the ICU in the first place. You can sit and watch your body take a much needed dirt nap where you got gacked, for as long as you like before choosing to go to the hospital, and wait to be revived if someone has that ability, or just soak up some experience and crack bad jokes if the remainder of your team manages to clean up the area. Rather than losing experience when you die, you rack up debt. Half of the experience you earn goes towards paying the debt off until you're back in the black. The best part about inspirations, though, is that there are ones that allow any hero, regardless of archetype or powers, to revive themselves right where they are. You're not combat-ready when you wake up, so don't try to take a walk in the middle of a melee. It takes some time for the disorientation to wear off, but it beats having to walk from the hospital to get back to the action. Between this and the healing inspirations, it allows teams to go without dedicated healers in many areas and allows individual heroes to solo more effectively. And really, what's more comic-booky than the miraculous return of a hero everyone thought had snuffed it?

You may also like to know that you can't die from falling damage; good to know when you're flying or teleporting across the city and suddenly run out of endurance a thousand feet up. Also, it makes for cheap entertainment with so many tall buildings and statues around. Top 'o the world, ma!

Duke it out!

Don't think you'll get away with using autoattack here, boys and girls; it's available but not really a viable option. Combat is fast-paced, and will require using a wide range of your available powers to get the job done right. Your powers recharge at different rates, as well, so if you're going to keep busy blasting away you'll have to mix it up a bit.

Display full image
To keep the fight flowing and prevent a network hiccup during a fight from causing your hero to do his best Gandhi impression, you can queue a power up to be used as soon as the current one has finished. This is immensely useful, but unfortunately won't work if your character is disoriented or under a similar affliction.

All heroes get three basic powers: brawl, sprint, and rest. Brawl is your ordinary punching attack, and a fun though risky way for non-melee types to get in the last hit on ailing villains. Sprint gives you a small boost in running speed, nowhere near as much as Super Speed, but enough to outpace enemies in a run to safety when things are looking grim. Resting allows you to regenerate health and stamina very quickly, but leaves you vulnerable while doing so and has a very long recharge time. Fortunately, it's not usually necessary. Your stamina recovers very quickly out of battle, and healing powers and inspirations deal with health problems, allowing you to leap back into battle with little delay.

Assisting another hero is as easy as targeting him and activating your powers as though to use it on them; this is absolutely invaluable, as hitting tab to cycle through available targets is horribly ineffective in large battles, and for some reason tends to choose enemies hundreds of yards away over the ones right in front of you.

Experience division is partly based on effort. If you do 95% of the damage to a Mortificator, and some random Joe Superpower swoops in and knocks it over, they may get 1 or 2 experience, but you get the majority. This feature cuts both ways, though; if a Nebel Fist you've confused takes out an Outcast Slammer, you get no experience. Of course, teams divide experience the same regardless of who did how much damage, so support roles need not fear losing out.

Perhaps the best feature of the entire game is the sidekick system. A higher level hero can take on a lower level one as a sidekick, effectively increasing the sidekick's level to just below their own. The sidekick doesn't get the extra powers that they would have if they really were that level, but their existing powers are boosted so that they're at least roughly a match for villains of a similar level. Finally, you can play with your friends' already-developed characters when you're just starting out without anyone in the team being bored stiff. It also makes filling up team slots that much easier, since you don't have to worry as much about other heroes' levels.

The Community

Speaking of teams, I've been hearing from a number of people that there just aren't groups to be had. Well, from what I've seen from my soapbox perch here, I can tell you these people couldn't have been trying very hard. I gave all the archetypes a whirl, some for longer than others, but the only time I ever had any trouble at all finding a teamup was in the wee hours of the morning, and even then finding at least one other person to fight alongside wasn't that hard. There's even a convenient "seek team" toggle and hero finder window.

Display full image
Teams just work. I've been on teams composed of nothing but blasters and controllers, or a blaster and a couple scrappers, or one defender and a controller, as well as more balanced mixes. Aside from one unbalanced team on a particularly brutal task force mission, none of them had any problems a second shot at the fight couldn't solve. The only exception to this is the occasional mission boss that is almost literally untouchable due to being several levels higher than anyone in the group; aside from burning as many inspirations as you can, the only way to beat them then is to go recruit a higher level hero to help out just for that battle. Luckily, the development team is aware of the problem and is already tweaking difficulty settings to correct the problem.

Your fellow heroes are friendly, too! Higher level heroes stop to help out lower level ones in need as often as they do for Paragon City citizens, and trading enhancements is often quicker, cheaper, and more effective than buying and selling them at store. Inspirations change hands simply as a matter of course, going where they're needed and can be of the most use.

If you're not very group-inclined, your progress will be slower, but it is doable provided you plan your powers around it. Pick your powers carefully if you go down this path; some archetypes or power combinations just won't work. For instance, I have a controller who can incapacitate enemies with the best of them, but who couldn't defeat even one without burning through most of his endurance, and it would take forever to boot.

Paragon City

Take me down, to Paragon City where the thugs are mean and the girls are pretty!

Paragon City, land of the superpowered and the criminally insane! If you're a normal, be prepared to pay out the nose for insurance, as property damage and personal injury are virtually assured! If you're a super, throw away that on-call pager, you're always on duty! The city has an interesting and rather calamitous past, leading up to its positively apocalyptic present; give it a read on the official site.

There's everything from parks to industrial zones, skyscrapers to chasms, (relatively) peaceful boroughs to disaster areas, and each zone has its own particular feel to it. Galaxy City and Atlas Park are bright, open areas that show the more hopeful side of the city; Skyway is a mass of highways and overpasses. King's Row is a dirty, dingy amalgamation of industrial facilities, power lines, pipework, and filthy water. Boomtown is a huge expanse of sheer devastation. And these are just the lower level zones!

Display full image
Zones are bordered by high walls topped by blue energy fields, ostensibly as a hedge against further alien invasion. Some areas, known as trial zones, have level requirements to enter. This isn't to say that you'll never find yourself confronted by enemies you can't handle; on the contrary, there's a good mix of enemy levels in any given zone, and you'll learn to avoid some neighborhoods at certain levels. Criminal factions sometimes meet on each other's turf, so be sure of what you're shooting at; that harmless looking group of Hellions may be blocking your view of the higher level Button Men mafiosos that are terrorizing them.

There's a wide range of enemies, including gang members, mafia, cultists and summoned demons, Nazis, zombies, freaks, aliens, martial artists, and mechanical constructs; you'll never lack for evil-minded punching bags. Like other MMORPGs, City of Heroes uses a color-coded conning system to allow you to gauge their difficulty. Generally, enemies of higher level con tougher, but there are also times when enemies of your level can be much tougher than you. This is especially the case in instanced "door" missions, where a small separate area accessible only to you and your team members is spawned off. In these missions, the level of the enemies within is determined primarily by the level of the character whose mission it is, while the number of enemies scales up with the number of heroes in the team to ensure there is always an appropriate level of challenge.

Not only are some missions instanced, but main zones are often instanced as well in order to prevent too many heroes from clogging the streets. Zone boundaries and the elevated train system will prompt you for which instance you'd like to go to, so be sure you know which one your team is waiting for you in. Another nice touch is that enemies never spawn in view; it all happens clandestinely, while you're not looking, as good criminal organizations ought to. Citizens you rescue thank you profusely, and passersby have not only heard of you but speak of your heroic deeds, while your foes bemoan your interference in their dastardly plots.

Right from the start, even in the required tutorial for new characters, the game pulls you in and gets you involved through your hero's contacts, who assign missions and eventually introduce you to new contacts. Missions are generally of a "go there and defeat these enemies" nature, but they provide more purpose and direction than simply wandering around and beating on whatever's convenient. They also grant significant experience bonuses upon completion, and series of related missions form plot arcs that involve discovering and foiling a group's schemes. Plot arc missions also come in task force form; the main distinctions being that once started, the task force group can't add new members, and the only ways out are to quit the task force (you can't re-join, either), or complete the hours-long arc.

Display full image
The missions and especially the task forces add some degree of depth and purpose to your actions, but they have their weak points. For one, there isn't a lot to interact with in them aside from enemies. You can only interact with objects that shine, and these only appear when you need to, say, find a clue or disarm a bomb, and the only doors you can open are the exit and elevator doors to go to the next floor. The maps all seem cut out of a larger whole map for any given type of area; if you've been through one office building, you've been through them all. Not a big issue, but it would be nice to see more random arrangements eventually. The instanced areas lack personality in general, however; this is probably the game's biggest flaw, though it's not nearly as bad as that makes it sound. About the most colorful things in the instanced areas are pieces of blurry corporate art in office environments and the occasional vending machine. Nightclubs are warehouses are factories, with the sole distinguishing feature being the mission details in your navigation bar.

Don't get me wrong; the game isn't completely devoid of character. The cave and high-tech lab instanced areas are beautiful, to say nothing of the main zones. You often run across gangs negotiating with or threatening each other, or gang members trying to pull a purse from a woman's grasp, or hammering on a car door lock. Clockwork automata can be seen carting off construction equipment or assembling more clockworks. There's plenty of villain banter to overhear as you pass close to any given group of enemies, and special dialogue around mission bosses. Office buildings have server rooms, and their meeting room whiteboards are fun to inspect. But what character it has isn't quite enough. Running across room after room of enemies standing around or milling about aimlessly just seems...odd, and some groups in particular seem to lack or just not use their characteristic idle animations. Milling about is fine for zombies, but you'd expect a military organization like the Fifth Column to keep a tighter ship; snap to, soldier! Gang members shouldn't be lounging around like they're in a high school hallway between classes. Take some target practice on the wall, or do some gambling or practice fighting! I know you can do it, I've seen it on the streets, you slackers! And while some enemies come complete with creepy sound effects, I have yet to hear any maniacal laughter.

Speaking of sound effects, aside from the aforementioned lack of insane cackling, there can be no complaint. Punches land with satisfying thwocks and smacks, blasts are appropriately zotty and bursty, and other actions have their own suitable onomatopoeian effects. The music seems to only play for short bursts when you enter a different section of a zone, to set the tone for the area, which is a shame because it's actually quite good.

The City of Tomorrow The big question everyone seems to be asking is, of course, whether City of Heroes will be anything more than a one-shot thrill. Well, if Cryptic and NCSoft can deliver on everything they have planned, there will be superheroes on the prowl in Paragon City for many years to come.

The biggest bonus is that they're planning ongoing content additions. These aren't just overhyped patches fixing existing issues or tweaking power effects, but completely new content - free! The first one, Through the Looking Glass, is already available for download, though the new features haven't gone live yet. It will raise the level cap to 50, add new zones, new villain groups, and allow you to change parts of your costume. Missions also get some revamping, including new outdoor instanced missions and adding a couple twists to existing ones, such as prison scenarios where you'll have to fight your way out from a cell, and lab equipment that gives you a random buff/debuff if you destroy it. This is going to go a long way towards adding needed interactivity to mission areas, and bodes well for future updates.

Rumor has it that supergroups will eventually have a bank vault for easy sharing of enhancements, and better yet, their own headquarters! Details, including implementation dates, are nigh unto nonexistent, so only time will tell.

There's also a monthly comic book that has already started shipping to the game's subscribers as part of the service. The comic will parallel in-game events and updates, and eventually include player characters and fan submissions. Even if you're not a big comic book fan, you have to hand it to them for the amount of effort going into making the game as immersive as possible.
Display full image

The Exciting Conclusion!

The vistas are breathtaking, the character customization is beyond all expectation, and it's just plain fun to play. The game mechanics are engaging enough that you can simply choose your powers and jump in fighting, yet deep enough that planning out your powers and enhancements can be a pastime of its own. Content updates will ensure that there's always something new to do, and starting a new character with radically different powers is always an option as well. The upcoming expansion, City of Villains, should shake things up even more, and make for some terrific PVP battles. Whether you're a long-time MMORPG veteran or still just wondering what all the fuss is about, I highly recommend giving City of Heroes a shot.

So, sidekick, are you ready to make a name for yourself in Paragon City?





The Verdict
Graphics (10%) 85%
Sound (10%) 80%
Control (10%) 90%
Community (15%) 95%
Game World (15%) 90%
Fun (40%) 95%
Overall 91%

The ups and downs:
Excellent Costume and Power CuSome Enemy Groups Need More Pe
Great BackstoryInstanced Areas Very Repetetiv
Frequent, Free Content UpdatesTask Forces May Be Too Long Fo
Easy GroupingAlmost No Music

Reviewer's System
Version: 06/2004
CPU: P4 2.8
RAM: 1024MB PC3200
Graphics 64MB GeForce 4 Ti4200
Sound SB Audigy 2 ZS
OS: WinXP Pro

Average Reader Ratings: 7.15 (26 votes)
Rate this title and view comments     Game Info     Printer Friendly Version

 
 
All original content of this site is copyrighted by RPGWatch. Copying or reproducing of any part of this site is strictly prohibited. Taking anything from this site without authorisation will be considered stealing and we'll be forced to visit you and jump on your legs until you give it back.